Documentation map
Conditional mutual information of adjacent intervals as a quantum-Markov defect. These pages are generated from the project's knowledge base by tools/build_docs.py, so what they say about a result is what the knowledge base says about it, with the same status word.
The four headline results
| result | status | page |
|---|---|---|
| Theorem A: lim Phi/zeta^2 = c/(12 pi^2) | refereed | thm-a-quadratic-law |
| Theorem B: f2 = c/(12 pi^2) for every diffeomorphism-covariant net | refereed — stated under H1, H2, H3 | thm-b-universality |
| The all-channel second-order optimum equals the isometric-orbit value: kappa_opt = 1 - theta = 0.616 +- 0.003 (numerical; conditional on H1, H2, H3) | numerical — conditional on H1, H2, H3 | all-channel-optimum-value |
| Corner calculus: sequential one-sided recovery = Schwarzian point masses at the junctions | proved — conditional on H | corner-calculus |
A status word is a claim about how much is known, and nothing more. numerical means measured, with an error bar; it is not a theorem. Where a row above says conditional, at least part of the statement holds only under the named hypotheses; they are quoted on the result's own page, and the badge must not be read without them. Stated under means the statement carries a hypothesis list of its own, quoted there as well.
The pages
| page | what it holds |
|---|---|
index.md | Map of the documentation |
status.md | Every claim, by area, with its status |
results/ | One page per consequential claim |
notation.md | Symbols and conventions |
definitions.md | The objects and what they mean |
open.md | What is open, and the recorded next step |
sources.md | External sources and how to obtain them |
history.md | Phases 1 to 6, and the errata |
The interactive site lives in this same folder and opens at index.html; it is built by the other tools of tools/ and shares these statuses.
Status vocabulary
| status | claims | meaning |
|---|---|---|
refereed | 3 | a complete structured proof that an independent referee pass has accepted |
proved | 40 | a complete structured proof |
numerical | 25 | measured, with an error bar and a convergence order; not a theorem |
conjectural | 11 | believed, with partial evidence; not proved |
verified | 5 | a check that was carried out and agreed |
open | 5 | an unsettled question |
active | 14 | work in progress |
done | 5 | a finished piece of project work |
superseded | 2 | replaced by a later claim |
refuted | 3 | shown to be false, kept so the correction stays visible |
heuristic | 2 | — |
Every claim with a page, by area
One page per claim whose status is refereed, proved, numerical, conjectural. The remaining claims are listed, with their status, in status.md.
Foundations: CMI as a Markov defect (Notes 1-3)
provedThree faces of the Bures form (type III)provedCMI as the data-processing defect of tracing out C (Note 2)provedLongo-Xu CMI of adjacent intervals for the free fermion net A_r, its finite-index subnets and extensionsprovedType-III second-variation lemma (fidelity half), under the vector hypothesis (V)conjecturalLongo-Xu Remark 4.3: adjacent-interval CMI (c/6) log(1+z) for every rational conformal net (conjecture)
Theorem A: exact recovery error of the free fermion
refereedTheorem A: lim Phi/zeta^2 = c/(12 pi^2)provedThe C^{1,1} extension of the zero-collar map is implementable on Fock space (uhlmann_upper_bound.tex Cor. 2.7, Prop. 3.1)provedf2 = c/(12 pi^2)provedFree-fermion one-particle metrics of the compression direction: g_B = 2r/(3 pi^2), g_KM = r/6 (c = r)provedZero-collar Petz map of the free fermion is a geometric compressionprovedPhi(zeta) and D(zeta) are nondecreasing in zeta (check_note5_theory.tex Prop. 8.1)provedExact root fidelity of two quasi-free CAR states from their symbols (Note 5 Thm. 2.1)provedRemainder of Theorem A: global upper bound Phi <= -(1/2) log(1 - 2 f2 zeta^2); c3 <= 0 as a limsup; no positive log^-2 termprovedRemainder bound in the settled range: Phi(zeta) <= -1/2 log(1 - 2 f2 zeta^2) for 0 <= zeta < (4 f2)^{-1/2} = pi sqrt(3)provedUltraviolet tail bound for the windowed fidelity (shape proved; explicit constants 0.173, 0.88 rest on numerical inputs)provedTwo-chirality law for the massless Dirac fermion: -log F^(lambda) = Phi(z(1+e^{-pi lambda})) + Phi(z(1+e^{pi lambda})), even in lambdaprovedExact x-space Mellin transform W-hat(k) of the <TT> kernel and its KMS relationnumericalCertified enclosures of the compressed recovery errornumericalContinuum Phi at large zeta and the drifting exponentnumericalWeak link: Phi(zeta) <= 0.0085 zeta^2 on (0, 1] (rigorous on (0, 0.8868], numerical on [0.8868, 1])numericalWeak link: numerical values of the tail constants A_1 <= 2.0 and A_3 <= 0.0374conjecturalIndex zero for e^{sK} beyond ||G_s||_2 < 1: for a unitary group e^{sK} with [P_-, K] Hilbert-Schmidt the two off-diagonal blocks have the same singular values also where |s| ||[P_-, K]||_2 >= 1 (open; no document contains an argument)conjecturalTwo-chirality law for a general 2D CFT (rests on an unproved chiral factorisation)conjecturalTwo-chirality minimum: for the massless Dirac fermion -log F^(lambda) is minimal at lambda = 0 for every z (unproved)
Theorem B: universality for diffeomorphism-covariant nets
refereed(H1)-(H3) hold for all diffeomorphism-covariant netsrefereedTheorem B: f2 = c/(12 pi^2) for every diffeomorphism-covariant netprovedg_B = 2c/(3 pi^2) for the compression direction of every diffeomorphism-covariant net (corollary of Theorem B)provedStress-tensor normalisation chainnumericalBosonic check: U(1) current net agrees
Kubo-Mori (relative entropy) coefficient s2
provedExact relative-entropy identity on unitary orbits (bounded generators; affiliated generators with Omega in D(A))conjecturals2 = c/12 for general netsconjecturalg_KM = c/6 for the compression direction of a general conformal net (conjecture; only the analytically continued value exists)
Optimality of recovery channels (O8, Phases 3 and 3b)
provedA-C restriction bound: (Tcond) implies E_AC = 0 exactly; applied on the hopping chain (4,8,2), (4,12,2), (4,16,2)provedAll-channel second-order optimum = quasi-free SDP valueprovedEvery recovery channel's recovered symbol is quasi-free feasibleprovedThe first-order compression defect is a commutator with the vacuum symbol: ddelta = [Q, E_I D_chi E_I] (F1 Lemma 6.1)provedExterior directions exhaust the invisible space: closure(Ext) = N^perp (question (Q) settled, YES)provedExact KKT certificate at the compression; Moebius rigidityprovedKKT sign criterion: when the isometric orbit carries the all-channel second-order optimumprovedMoebius reduction: the fidelity and relative entropy of the geometric recovery depend on (a, L, s) only through zeta = a s/(a+L), including the half-line chart a = infinity (zeta = s) (Note 5 Lemma 1.1; check_note5_theory prop:closed)provedThe Petz map is not second-order optimal (compression 4x better at leading order)provedSecond-order problem over quasi-free channels is a convex SDPprovedSecond-order (SLD / quantum Fisher) expansion of the quasi-free root fidelity in finite dimensions (Note 5 Prop. 2.3)provedExact single-observable fidelity bound (Alberti-Uhlmann) and its reduction to the recovered symbolprovedExact (N,Y,V) chart of F and the tangent problem at the compressionprovedThe theta-problem in the modular frame of the half-line is a parameter-free quadratic Wiener-Hopf problem (F1 Prop. 6.2)proved(UH) proved: optimised Uhlmann bound = g_Q of the defect, for every isometric quasi-free channelnumericalHopping chain: T = Q_AB^+ Q_AC satisfies the A-C intertwining conditions (Tcond) for (L_A,L_B,L_C) = (4,8,2), (4,12,2), (4,16,2)numericalThe all-channel second-order optimum equals the isometric-orbit value: kappa_opt = 1 - theta = 0.616 +- 0.003 (numerical; conditional on H1, H2, H3)numericalS10's circle model: the ultraviolet taper suppresses theta by ~20%, and there is no taper-free limitnumericalE_rec <= (1-theta) f2 z^2 (1+o(1)): the zero-collar compression is NOT optimal in exact fidelitynumericalThe compression is not the minimiser of the second-order functionalnumericalExact -1/2 log det(1-V^*V) with the optimised extension confirms (UH) beyond first ordernumericalNS-circle model: Ext = N^perp exactly, with the dimension identity (L-|I|)^2numericalmpmath at 60-80 digits: dist((1-Pi)M, Ext) = 0 exactlynumericalOptimised exterior extension: UB_c = (1/2)s^2|u|^2 exactly and UB_rot/UB_c = 1-thetanumericalIs the compression beaten in EXACT fidelity?numericalFinite chains: exterior directions span exactly the invisible space (Ext = N^perp)numericalFull primal SDP over F in the modular Galerkin frame: min_F g_Q = 8.41 and 7.13 times g_Q(delta_c) at h = 0.4, 0.3 -- the S11 representability obstruction, not a statement about non-isometric channelsnumericalKKT criterion numerics: every finite run FAILS (a); the violation extrapolates to 0^- as h -> 0, Ymax -> inf; under H3, (e) follows from the proved E(zeta_inf) >= 0 alone, and the finite-h junction values are positivenumericalStructure of the numerical optimumnumericalTangent SDP over (G, N1, Y1) in the circle model: orbit-only optimum matches (1-theta) to 1.1e-7, full optimum not resolvable (measured Gram cond 2.4e22)numericalThe first-order gain constant theta = 0.384 +- 0.003 (S10's 0.300 is a taper-suppressed lower bound)conjecturalHypothesis H1 of the tangent problem: g_Q-differentiability along the scaled familyconjecturalHypothesis H2 of the tangent problem: localisation of the minimisers of the second-order programmeconjecturalHypothesis H3 of the tangent problem (cone hypothesis): every admissible isometry generator with a feasible first-order datum lies in the model cone modulo the linear class
Lattice, thermal, massive and gapped geometries (O7, O9, O10)
provedCorner calculus: sequential one-sided recovery = Schwarzian point masses at the junctionsprovedSeparation constraint: all-weak L->R Petz chains have e^{Delta_k} >= 2/eps (sharp)provedAmplification: the corner strength in the chain frame is zeta_step (1 + z')provedCorner data of all one-sided protocols for n = 4 and n = 5: the holonomy is the starting blockprovedAngle form of the sequential recovery bound, conditional on Hypothesis (U) (vacuous: (U) is refuted)provedType-III sequential recovery bound: Bures distances add along a chain of von Neumann inclusions (chordal and second-order forms, no Hypothesis (U))provedVacuum rigidity: the pulled-back vacuum is the vacuum iff the map is Moebius; no protocol recovers exactlynumericalSeparated intervals: CMI with a gap and linearity off criticalitynumericalMarkov c-function along the massive flownumericalThermal states: two-branch law at the cylinder cross ratio, exponential shieldingnumericalTwo-branch law confirmed on the latticeconjecturalSecond-order network law: Phi_tot = sum zeta_j zeta_k G(y_j - y_k), G = c Ghat universalconjecturalVWZ four-interval protocols: Phi(1):Phi(2):Phi(3) -> 1:2:4; middle-out is the worst order
How these pages are built
tools/build_docs.py reads the knowledge base and writes every page here except notation.md and definitions.md, which it assembles once from the conventions appendices and then leaves alone. tools/build_docs.py --check regenerates into a temporary directory and fails if anything committed differs, so a page cannot drift away from the claim it describes.
Evidence pointers that resolve into the private companion (source papers, page excerpts, and the five cited-result compendia, none of which may be redistributed) are shown as held privately, not redistributed instead of as links; which paths are public is decided by asking git, not by a list in the script. Statements and verification recipes are quoted verbatim, so their prose may still name such material — the page excerpts under rigor/shots/, the source PDFs under refs/, and the five cited-result compendia — which a clone will not contain; see THIRD-PARTY.md and sources.md.